Кузнецов Дмитрий Юрьевич : другие произведения.


Самиздат: [Регистрация] [Найти] [Рейтинги] [Обсуждения] [Новинки] [Обзоры] [Помощь|Техвопросы]

 Ваша оценка:
  • Аннотация:
    knowledge based on set of irrefutable dogmats

Русская версия этой статьи

Religion is kind of human knowledge based on some specific (canonic) set of irrefutable concepts, texts, believes, symbols, and practice.
Typically, religions are characterized in the following:
1. The existence of at least one God is assumed. God is some subject that in some way, that is not available to humankind, has abilities that greatly exceed the abilities of any human.
2. The human is supposed to recognize the will of God and obey it.
3. God likes some actions and activities of humans; these actions and activities are qualified as good.
4. God dislike some actions and activities of humans; these actions and activities are qualified as evil, or bad.
5. The set of concepts at least pretends to play an organizing role in the society, and/or to lead it to the happiness and the prosperity,
6. In general, the follower of the religion is supposed to be more powerful, wise, noble and generous than followers of other religions.
Some branches of some religion are so dogmatic that they do not identify themselves as religions, but as "the only true" knowledge; then, followers of other religions are considered as bad, infidel, and are supposed to be punished. Often, the dogmatic religions are aggressive with respect to any other concepts, that declare them not only "false" but even crime.
Some other religions allow the deviations of the believe from the canonic concepts, do not imply the punishment of the "infidel" humans just for having a "wrong" believe; however, it is supposed that the "true" believe helps to the humankind to do good things and to avoid any evil thing.

Examples of religions

The most known religions are Islam (the adepts call themselves muslims), Christianity, Judaism, Marxism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Paganism, Pluralism (or Positivistic Pluralism),

The classification of religions by cases above it approximate; within the most of kinds, there are species, that are pretty different from each other. For example, the catholics (branch of christianity) may kill protestants (another branch of christianity) just for being adepts of protestantism; the stalinists (branch of marxism) may kill the Trotskyists (another branch of marxism) just for being adepts of Trotskyism, id est, for the belonging to the "wrong" branch of the same religion.

Role of religion in the human society

The religion takes the special role in the human knowledge. Most of achievements and tragedies of human civilizations and associated with some religion.

The Arabian civilization, that brought the humankind the fundamentals of Al-Gebra, was based on the Islam.

The so-called Western civilization, that brought many technical achievements, used in IXX and XX centuries (steam machines, cars, aircrafts, opto-electric devices, computers) were based mainly on the Judaism and the Christianity, although the achievement of the Roman Empire in the Science of Law (used until now) seem to be related with the Polytheism.

The philosophy of pacifism, which allows the human civilizations to avoid at least big military conflicts already during more than half-century (touch a wood!), came from countries, where the dominant religion is Hinduism, and is closely related to the Hinduism.

The Religion-less societies almost did not exist in the human history. There were few intents to build-up a society that exclude the religion. Such communities ether did not last long, as the Paris Commune, or led to creation of a new religion, for example, the Marxism (called also Marxism-Leninism, as it happened at the beginning of the Soviet Union.

Many documents, that survived during centuries, assume the existence of Gog(s), and often, God(s) play the important role in the topic of the text. This indicate that religions should be considered as important part of the human knowledge.
Many religions, like the christianity, and the marxizm-leninism have some of elements, typical also for the science; they try to systemize their concept and develop them using some elements of logics. However, all the religions, including even the positivistic pluralism fail the requirement of negability. According to R.Kipling, the truly religious person should believe in his "fait" even if all around indicates the error. ("Trust yourself, when all men doubt you"). In addition, many of them (like Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Marxism-Leninism) fail also the requirement of pluralism, which deviates them from the scientific knowledge.

Since the beginning or the documented history, the religion plays important role in the human society. There were several intents to substitute the religion with the common sense and science, but these intents were not successful.

Classification of religions

The main specification of religions indicates, how many gods does it assume. This classifies the religion as monotheistic or polytheistic. The most radical monotheistic religions seems to be Judaism. Islam also pretends to be monotheistic, but allows existence of Devil, who also in some sense, has certain power, that greatly exceed the human abilities and is not available for humans. Some intermediate position takes the Christianity, that assumes not only existence of Devil, but also Jesus and apostles, who used to handle the Power, that usually is not available for humans; any scientific intent to learn and use such an ability is considered as evil. In polytheistic religions, many Gods are assumed; sometimes, each of gods handles his or her own area of deals, and even conflicts between Gods are allowed.

Practice of the religion

Usually, religion assume certain specific practice. This practice may includes prays, reading the scared books, it may include special singing, dance, body modifications, and sacrifices. The meaning of sacrifices varies from one religion to another. The extremal case of sacrifices is the human sacrifice, id est, the ritual kill, massacre of humankind. In many cases the sacrificed humans were not condemned in doing anything bad to other humans directly, but to a God, making him discontent with the humankind and in such a way bringing the disasters to humans. It was assumed, that after the sacrifice, the God become more content and kindly with the survivors. In some cultures, the human sacrifices could be used to regulate the population. Often, the religious sacrifice does not require killing of a human(s); but means that the adept dedicates his life to the serve to God; the adept makes things that pleases God.

Taboos of religions

Usually, the religion specifies the things that should not be done under any conditions. The Categorical imperative specifies the set of actions, the religious human should not do on any conditions. The religious fait is considered as strong tool to survive the anti-humanistic conditions, caused by an accident or by the religious fanatics (usually, fanats of another religion).

Religion and other kinds of human knowledge

Religion is related with the customs (unwritten rules), folklor, literature, art and science. Often, the religious customs are mixed, confused with the canons, described in the canonical texts. These texts, in their turn, often are used as subject in literature and art (for example, paintings). In addition, the narration, legends can be used for creation of new religions.

Especially strong is interaction between religion and science. Several authors believed, that the religion somehow contradict the Science, and many disputes were around this. Usually, the participants believed, that the existence or non-existence of God can be proved. Often, the adepts of the official religion used their power for the physical suppression or even elimination sacrifice of opponents. The documents indicate that Catholics in XIII-XVII centuries and marxists during the Soviet Union acted namely in this way. During centuries, the Helio-centric system of world had problems if such a kind, then the theory of evolution of Darwin in Europe, then the Genetics, Theory of Relativity, Quantum Mechanics, Cybernetics, and then Psychiatry were destroyed in the Soviet Union, using the religious concepts of marxism.

Often, the discussion of the contradiction of religion and science is based on the implicit assumption that religion allows the negability a concept (that means that within the concept, the experiment that negates it, can be described). For example, in the Christianity, no experiment, no observation that would show the non-existence of God, is allowed. In the similar way, in the marxism, neither experiments, nor observations are allowed to show, that the concepts of the histmat and dimamat are wrong. Even after the crash of the USSR, some marxists believe, that the prosper society can be constructed on the dogmas histmat and dimamat.

The truly religious human does not need any proof of his believe; on just uses the religious concepts in his life. Then, no contradiction between science and religion happens. The believer just follows the rule Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar"s, and unto God the things that are God"s in Christianity, or its equivalent in other religion, without to enter into any Controversies.


The religion plays important role in all human societies. Some critics of religion may be quite a reasonable ad that by B.Russel, but the obvious observation is that there existed no religion-less prosper societies. If the religion does not dominate, does not suppress other kinds of the human knowledge, then it helps the society to keep its organization, developing sciences, human freedom and honesty.

External links:
http://www.users.drew.edu/%7Ejlenz/whynot.html Bertrand Russell. Why I Am Not A Christian. Lecture on March 6, 1927 to the National Secular Society, South London Branch, at Battersea Town Hall. Published in 1957.
http://www.positiveatheism.org/hist/russell2.htm Bertrand Russell. Has Religion Made Useful Contributions to Civilization? (Girard, KS: Haldeman-Julius, 1929)
http://scienceblogs.com/grrlscientist/2009/10/a_flowchart_to_determine_what.php source of the picture
Related articles in Vera:
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/absolutemoral.shtml About the absolute moral
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/philosophy.shtml Philosophy
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/science.shtml Science, set of refutable concepts
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/nihilisttaboo.shtml Taboos
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/forgiveness.shtml Forgiveness
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/demo.shtml Democracy for export
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/heroe.shtml National Hero
http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/000vera.shtml#e Vera, alphabetic index
Copyleft 2010 by Dmitrii Kouznetsov. This text may be used for free, attribute http://samlib.ru/k/kuznecow_d_j/religion.shtml
 Ваша оценка:

Связаться с программистом сайта.

Новые книги авторов СИ, вышедшие из печати:
О.Болдырева "Крадуш. Чужие души" М.Николаев "Вторжение на Землю"

Как попасть в этoт список

Кожевенное мастерство | Сайт "Художники" | Доска об'явлений "Книги"